Russia May Weaponize Ukrainian Agriculture
Updated: Mar 8, 2022
Russian “Farm to Table” Domination of World Agriculture
As Russia’s military is at the cusp of conducting a hostile takeover of Ukraine, energy and gold prices are soaring as I forecast in my SA article published 16 January 2022 Energy and Gold Prices to Soar After Likely Russian Invasion, global food prices will rise as dramatically as their energy & gold counterparts as Russia controls Europe’s breadbasket. It remains to be seen whether Ukrainian agribusiness will be able to plant, harvest and sell their agricultural products for export.
Logistically Russia’s navy controls the Black Sea and effectively blockades five critical Ukrainian ports utilized for grain exports: Odessa, Mykolaiv, Kherson, Mariupol and Berdyansk.
Ukrainian Agricultural Overview
The importance of Ukrainian grain production and exports cannot be overstated. The 2022 agricultural yield forecasts a considerable increase from previous years. Ukraine’s average annual yield is three times its domestic needs making them one of the world’s largest agricultural exporters.
The following data are particulars for each crop provided by the World Data Center for Geoinformatics and Sustainable Development:
· Ukraine’s grain output consists of wheat, corn, barley and rye.
· 4th largest exporter of corn (eastern and southern Ukraine), planted in April/May, harvested in September, and barley (eastern Ukraine), planted in April and harvested in August.
· 6th largest exporter of wheat (south and south-central Ukraine). It’s a winter wheat planted in fall and harvested the following summer.
· 7th largest exporter of soybeans.
· World’s leading sunflower seed oil exporter (southern and eastern regions), planted in April harvested in September. It’s their most profitable crop because of low production costs and high demand.
· Most exports are shipped to Spain and Italy, North Africa, the Middle East and East Asia (China, Japan, Korea).
· Russian and Ukrainian grain production represents 30% of the world inventory, a market share that doubled since 2014.
Global Food Supply & Prices
For the aforementioned reasons, there is great uncertainty after a Russian invasion and occupation as to what extent Ukraine will be permitted to continue agricultural operations and whether exports will be limited or even restricted.
World food prices began ascending dramatically in 2021 and will accelerate in 2022. The pre-war market factors are as follows:
· Higher prices for pesticides.
· Higher prices for fertilizers.
· Severe meteorological events such as floods & droughts have adversely impacted crop yields.
· Labor shortage in logistical and agricultural services.
· Global supply chain disruptions.
Finally the food export restriction policy of even small countries impacts global food prices as illustrated on the following link called the exponential domino effect in which a seemingly small and insignificant factor becomes a powerful multiplier effect that triggers an outsized crisis far beyond its domestic borders.
One such example is that in 2021 Russia placed export taxes on their grain crop to keep more inventory homebound. For this reason countries that purchased Russian grains were forced to search for alternative sources such as nearby Ukraine.
The following chart entitled Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations (FAO) food price index indicates an explosive price increase in major food categories. These food prices will skyrocket when war rages in Ukraine.
Russia & Ukraine Do Swimmingly Well in a Water Stressed World
Russian and Ukrainian agricultural production have enjoyed a stunning success of bountiful crops and whose harvest regions have avoided, by default or design, becoming water-stressed. As most other countries struggle with grain production in the future, Russia and Ukrainian grain production will be robust giving them increased market share and greater pricing leverage.
The following chart entitled Where Water Street Will Be the Highest in 2040 provided by the World Sources Institute via the Economist Intelligence Unit. The UN defines “water stress” as when a country withdraws least 25% of its renewable freshwater supply.
Agricultural Investment Opportunities
For the aforementioned reasons, I believe there’s strong immediate to long-term bullish prices in the agricultural sector, investment opportunities with ETFs and ETNs.
As a refresher with respect to their basic differences, an ETF one invests in a fund of the asset that it tracks while an ETN is like a bond, an unsecured debt note issued by an institution.
A comprehensive listing and description of these agricultural ETFs and ETNs are in the ETF database entitled Definitive List of Agricultural Commodities. Each type investment provides a comprehensive description of the fund and level of risk.
With respect to grains, the titles and links to these categories are as follows:
Despite the rise in global agricultural indices I don’t believe the market has fully priced in the war risk whether it be a temporary blockade or long-term limit or restriction of Ukrainian exports.
A Russian invasion and occupation will further squeeze an already tightening food market since many governments have, officially and unofficially, limited or even banned outright export of domestic agricultural products. This has been done for the purposes of food security and maintaining affordable food prices to avoid socio-political instability.
For all the aforementioned reasons I forecast dramatically rising agricultural prices and recommend a “buy” on the above agricultural investments.
© Copyright 2022 Cerulean Council LLC
The Cerulean Council is a NYC-based think-tank that provides prescient, beyond-the-horizon, contrarian perspectives and risk assessments on geopolitical dynamics and global urban security.